ROAS vs ROI: The 'Profitability Paradox' in Google Ads (2024)

"We have a 4.0 ROAS!" "Great. Are we making money?" "I don't know."

This is a real conversation we have with audit leads every week. Advertisers obsess over ROAS (Return on Ad Spend) because it is the default metric in the Google Ads dashboard. But ROAS is a vanity metric if you don't understand your margins.

In this guide, we are going to teach you the Financial Mechanics of PPC. You aren't just buying clicks; you are buying future cash flow.

---

Part 1: The Definitions (Simple Math)

ROAS (The Revenue Metric)

Formula: Total Revenue / Total Ad Spend

• Spend: $1,000
• Revenue: $4,000
• ROAS: 4.0 (or 400%)

ROAS tells you: "For every dollar I put in the machine, how many dollars come out the top?" It does NOT tell you if you kept any of those dollars.

ROI (The Business Metric)

Formula: (Net Profit - Total Cost) / Total Cost

• Spend: $1,000
• Cost of Goods (COGS): $2,500
• Shipping/Handling: $200
• Total Revenue: $4,000
• Net Profit: $300
• ROI: 8%

ROI tells you: "Is this activity actually building wealth for the company?"

---

Part 2: The "Break-Even ROAS" Formula

You cannot set a ROAS target (e.g., "I want a 4.0 ROAS") arbitrarily. It must be derived from your margins.

The Formula: 1 / Profit Margin %

Scenario A: High Margin (SaaS / Digital)

• Product Cost: $0 (Software)
• Margin: 90% (0.9)
• Break-Even ROAS: 1 / 0.9 = 1.11
• Insight: You can afford an extremely low ROAS and still make money. A 2.0 ROAS is a money printer.

Scenario B: Low Margin (Reselling Electronics)

• Product Cost: $80 for a $100 item.
• Margin: 20% (0.2)
• Break-Even ROAS: 1 / 0.2 = 5.0
• Insight: If your agency gets you a 4.0 ROAS, you are losing money on every single sale.

Action Item: Calculate your Break-Even ROAS today. If your Target ROAS in Google Ads is lower than this number, pause the campaign immediately.

---

Part 3: Enter POAS (Profit On Ad Spend)

The industry is shifting to a new metric: POAS. This requires feeding your COGS (Cost of Goods Sold) data back into Google Ads.

• How it works:
  • User buys "Red Socks" ($10 margin) -> Google records $10 value.
  • User buys "Blue Suit" ($200 margin) -> Google records $200 value.
• The Optimization:
  • Smart Bidding (tROAS) now optimizes for Gross Profit, not just Revenue.
  • It will bid aggressively on high-margin items and pull back on low-margin items.

Implementation: You can do this using "Conversions with Cart Data" in Google Ads or third-party tools like ProfitMetrics.io.

---

Part 4: The SaaS Exception (LTV:CAC)

If you are in Subscription B2B or SaaS, ROAS is useless. Why? Because the "Conversion Value" of a free trial is $0.

You need to bid based on LTV (Lifetime Value).

The Math:

• Average Customer stays for 12 months.
• Pays $100/mo.
• LTV: $1,200.
• Target CAC Ratio: 3:1 (Standard SaaS Benchmark).
• Max Acquisition Cost: $400.

The Strategy: You set your Target CPA to $400. You will lose money on Day 1 (Spend $400 to get first month $100). But you will make massive ROI by Month 12.

The "Cash Flow Gap": Be careful. If you spend $400 to acquire a customer today, and they pay you back over 12 months, you need cash in the bank to float that gap. This is why SaaS startups raise VC money—to fund the "CAC Gap".

---

Summary

1. Calculate Break-Even ROAS: 1 / Margin.
2. Don't celebrate Revenue: Celebration Profit.
3. Use POAS: If you have variable margins (Ecommerce), integrate profit data.
4. Use LTV: If you have recurring revenue (SaaS), optimize for CAC, not ROAS.

Don't let the dashboard fool you. You can go bankrupt with a green line.